Guitar Hero or Real Guitars? The War Has Finally Kicked Off!

Published: Tue December 09, 2008  News Feed

UK daily broadsheet The Guardian has chosen to stick up for the games industry following an article in NME magazine that attacked titles like Rock Band and Guitar Hero for deterring kids from playing real musical instruments.



The NME piece quoted Q Radio presenter David Quantick as stating: “Games are not rock 'n' roll, they're metal – aggressive, loud, violent and scared of women. You can't dance to a game or have sex to it. Games are still for nerds. Rock 'n' roll is about f*****g, games are about w*****g. Rock music makes you leave the house and meet drugs, games make you stay in and smell of your own p**s.”

In response, Guardian blogger Keith Stuart today commented: “The piece begins with a rather familiar complaint, this time voiced by Chad Kroeger of Nickleback, that games like Guitar Hero are diverting kids away from taking up real instruments.

“Personally, I feel that if Guitar Hero has prevented the foundation of just one new Nickleback-inspired band, Harmonix, the creator the Guitar Hero series, should be given some sort of medal.”

Whose side are you on? Real Guitars or Guitar Hero? And - can't you like them both? Leave your comments on our Music Planet message board!

Related Products

SpongeBob Squarepants 3/4 Size Outfit with Built-in Speaker

Hey, SpongeBob guitars go punk - turn these guitars up way loud! How about the brilliant SpongeBob graphics on this fab-u-lous guitar? Neat 3/4 size twin cutaway body style, smooth forearm chamfer and rear ribcage contour, maple neck and fretboard, with a single coil pickup and single rotary Volume control all making this an exciting guitar to get into…

Web Price:

74.99

Availability:

10+ in stock
Buy Now More Info

Squier by Fender Start Playing SE Special Strat Electric Guitar Pack (Arctic White)

Great Starter Pack, that includes a SE Special Squier Strat (Arctic White) and a Squier SP-10 amp, as well as guitar stand, instructional DVD, cable, tuner gig bag, guitar strap and pick sampler. EVERYTHING you need to stop dreaming and start playing! Features: Model Name SE Special / Squier SP-10 Amp Model Number 030-1600-(Color#) Series SE 100 Series…

Web Price:

159.00

Availability:

10+ in stock
Buy Now More Info

Encore Electric Guitar Outfit Tele-Style (Sunburst)

The Encore E2 Blaster Pack gets you straight into the action with loads of great guitar tones from rock to country – all ready to happen! Contents • Encore E2 Electric Guitar
• B.B. Blaster 10 Watt Rehearsal Guitar Amp
• Qwik Tune Tuner
• Kinsman Carry Bag
• Kinsman…

Web Price:

109.00

Availability:

9 in stock
Buy Now More Info

Squier by Fender Start Playing SE Special Strat Pack (Sunburst)

Great Starter Pack, that includes a SE Special Squier Strat (Sunburst) and a Squier SP-10 amp, as well as guitar stand, instructional DVD, cable, tuner gig bag, guitar strap and pick sampler. EVERYTHING you need to stop dreaming and start playing! Features: Model Name SE Special / Squier SP-10 Amp Model Number 030-1600-(Color#) Series SE 100 Series…

Web Price:

159.00

Availability:

9 in stock
Buy Now More Info

Squier by Fender Start Playing SE Special Strat Pack (Black)

Great Starter Pack, that includes a SE Special Squier Strat (Black) and a Squier SP-10 amp, as well as guitar stand, instructional DVD, cable, tuner gig bag, guitar strap and pick sampler. EVERYTHING you need to stop dreaming and start playing! Features: Model Name SE Special / Squier SP-10 Amp Model Number 030-1600-(Color#) Series SE 100 Series…

Web Price:

159.00

Availability:

8 in stock
Buy Now More Info

Encore Electric Guitar Outfit Tele-Style (Gloss Black)

The Encore E2 Blaster Pack gets you straight into the action with loads of great guitar tones from rock to country – all ready to happen! Good quality, affordable starter pack. Contents Encore E2 Electric Guitar  B.B. Blaster 10 Watt Rehearsal Guitar Amp  Qwik Tune Tuner  Kinsman Carry Bag  Kinsman Guitar Stand  GYC Guitar Lead  Guitar Tech Guitar…

Web Price:

109.00

Availability:

7 in stock
Buy Now More Info

Encore Electric Guitar Outfit - Gloss Black

The Encore E6 ‘Play Now’ Blaster Pack is the UK’s best first electric guitar starter pack money can buy! Contents
• Encore E6 Electric Guitar
• B.B. Blaster 10 Watt Rehearsal Guitar Amp
• Qwik Tune Tuner
• Kinsman Carry Bag
• Kinsman Guitar Stand
• GYC…

Web Price:

109.00

Availability:

5 in stock
Buy Now More Info

Squier by Fender Stop Dreaming Start Playing HSS Strat Pack (Black, Rosewood neck)

Stop Dreaming, Start Playing™ Pack: Affinity Strat® HSS with Bullet® 150 DSP Amp

Features:

Model Name Stop Dreaming, Start Playing™ Pack: Affinity Strat® HSS with Bullet® 150 DSP Amp
Series Affinity Series
Polyurethane Finish
Body Agathis
Neck Maple, C-Shape, (Polyurethane Finish)
Fingerboard…

Web Price:

199.00

Availability:

5 in stock
Buy Now More Info

Squier by Fender Squier Affinity Strat HSS pack in Metallic Red with G-DEC Amp

Features:

Model Name Stop Dreaming, Start Playing™ Pack: Affinity Strat® HSS with G-DEC® Junior Amp
Series Affinity Series
Polyurethane Finish
Body Agathis
Neck Maple, C-Shape, (Polyurethane Finish)
Fingerboard Rosewood, 9.5” Radius (241 mm)
No. of Frets 22 Medium Jumbo
Pickups 2 Single-Coil…

Web Price:

199.99

Availability:

4 in stock
Buy Now More Info

Squier by Fender Stop Dreaming Start Playing HSS Strat Pack (Metallic red, rosewood neck)

Stop Dreaming, Start Playing™ Pack: Affinity Strat® HSS with Bullet® 150 DSP Amp

Features:

Model Name Stop Dreaming, Start Playing™ Pack: Affinity Strat® HSS with Bullet® 150 DSP Amp
Series Affinity Series
Polyurethane Finish
Body Agathis
Neck Maple, C-Shape, (Polyurethane Finish)
Fingerboard…

Web Price:

199.00

Availability:

4 in stock
Buy Now More Info
 
 

Sign-Up

Sign up now for special offers & industry news...

Optional extra lists you can sign up for...